How we source data
OnTheList is only useful if you can trust it. So every fact on every profile carries where it came from and the date it was true, and anything we don't know is marked Unknown rather than guessed.
Every fact is sourced and dated
Under each value you'll see its source type and an "as of" date; where the source is public, it links to it. When sources disagree, we use the more reliable one and note the conflict. In order of trust:
| Winery | The winery's own public site or materials. |
|---|---|
| Winery-supplied | Facts a winery sent us directly. Labeled separately from what it publishes. |
| Member offer | Dates, wines, prices and limits from list members' offer emails. Facts only; we never reproduce letters. |
| Member report | Reports submitted by readers. |
| Critic | Published critic reviews and scores. |
| Press | News and magazine coverage. |
| Secondary market | Average prices and auction results after release. |
| Release tracker | Third-party release calendars and retailer listings. |
| Forum report | Collector forum posts. Treated as the weakest evidence and used mainly for wait times. |
| Calculated | Worked out from other facts on the page, such as cost to stay on. |
| OnTheList | Our own judgment: the short version on each profile. |
Wait times
The realistic wait is the time from signing up to a first offer. We build it from real signup and offer dates, show it as a range with the number of reports behind it, and leave out reports more than about three years old. A winery's own estimate is shown as such.
Market vs. release, and our take
Market vs. release compares what a wine sells for after release with what list members paid. It's shown only where both prices are known, as the median across a list's tracked wines.
Each profile also has the short version: our plain-language take on who the list suits and what it's worth, saying what it rests on (price versus the market, access to list-only wines, wait, cost to stay on) and what data is still missing.
Independence pledge
- Wineries never pay for, preview or influence what we write about them.
- Wineries may correct a factual error with a source. They can't change our take, a wait estimate or a price comparison.
- If wineries ever receive anything from OnTheList, it will be aggregate data or introductions to readers who asked for them. Never access to individuals, and never an open channel to message readers.
- OnTheList never sells wine and takes no referral fees. Signup links go straight to the winery.
What we don't publish
We publish facts: dates, prices, quantities and rules. We don't reproduce wineries' letters, and we never publish anything that identifies a list member.
Corrections
If something is wrong or out of date, we want to know, ideally with a source.
A reader report form is coming soon. Until then, email hello@getonthelist.io.