OnTheList

All lists

Scarecrow

Napa Valley (Rutherford)

Cabernet Sauvignon

List
Waitlist
Realistic wait
30–48 months
Release prices
$250–$600
Market vs. release
+67% vs. release

Who this list is for

Napa Cabernet lovers who want a cult Rutherford wine and are happy to start with its second label. Joining is free. Everyone on the list is offered M. Etain (about $250 a bottle) each fall, so a first offer can come right away. The flagship Scarecrow (about $600) is offered each spring by list seniority after a wait of roughly 3-4 years. Passing on a flagship offer reportedly sends you to the back of the line.

Join the Scarecrow list

The link goes to the winery's own signup page. OnTheList doesn't sell wine or take a referral fee.

The short version

An M. Etain offer comes right away, and the flagship trades well above its $600 release.

Free to join, and the whole list gets the M. Etain second wine each fall at about $250, so new members can buy from the start. The flagship comes by seniority after about 3-4 years (three 2025 forum reports of 2.5-3 years; the winery now says about four). The 2021 Scarecrow averages about $1,220 against a $600 release and the 2022 about $780, both 97-100 points. M. Etain trades near its release price, so it is about access, not value. Gaps: flagship allocation size, 2023 Scarecrow release, offer windows.

Our take, as of 2026-11-18. How we write these

The list

StatuswaitlistMember offer · as of 2026-11-18
Realistic wait30–48 months (n=3; Time to the first flagship Scarecrow offer. Three forum reports from early 2025 (about 2.5, 3 and 3 years) set the low end; the winery's 2026 welcome email states an approximate four-year wait, used as the high end. M. Etain is offered to the whole list, so a first M. Etain offer can arrive on joining (a 2026 signup got one the same day).)Member offer · as of 2026-11-18
Minimum purchaseNone stated. The fall 2026 M. Etain offer allowed up to 8 bottles, sold as 2-packs or 6-packs, plus a magnum with any 750ml purchase.Member offer · as of 2026-11-18
Releases per year2Member offer · as of 2026-11-18
Offer windowUnknownas of 2026-11-18
If you skipDeclining a flagship offer within its time frame moves the member to the end of the waiting list.Forum report · as of 2025-02-01
Allocation guaranteeUnknownas of 2026-11-18
Cost to stay on, per yearUnknownas of 2026-11-18

Releases

Price per 750ml bottle. "Secondary" is what the wine sells for after release.

VintageWineReleaseSecondaryDifference
2024M. Etain$250Member offer · as of 2026-11-18Unknownas of 2026-11-18—
2023M. EtainUnknownas of 2026-11-18$252Secondary market · as of 2026-11-18—
2022Scarecrow Cabernet Sauvignon$600Release tracker · as of 2025-02-25$781Secondary market · as of 2026-11-18+30%
2021Scarecrow Cabernet Sauvignon$600Release tracker · as of 2024-03-01$1,221Secondary market · as of 2026-11-18+103%

Winery website

Get the weekly offer email

One short email a week: which allocation offers are open (Scarecrow included, when it has one), what closes soon and what's next. Free.

No spam, unsubscribe any time. Privacy.

Something wrong or out of date? Corrections with a source are welcome; see how we source data.