OnTheList

All lists

Williams Selyem

Russian River Valley (Healdsburg)

Pinot NoirChardonnayCabernet Sauvignon

List
Waitlist
Realistic wait
2–12 months
Release prices
$72–$245
Market vs. release
+39% vs. release

Who this list is for

Pinot Noir drinkers at every level: single-vineyard Russian River Pinots at $49-$90, with no fees and no minimums. The winery says the wait is a few months to a year. Buying the introductory offer secures future allocations, and spring buyers get first access to the most sought-after fall wine. A classic first list for learning Pinot Noir.

Join the Williams Selyem list

The link goes to the winery's own signup page. OnTheList doesn't sell wine or take a referral fee.

The short version

Pinot at $49-$90 with no minimum, and the Top-10 Eastside Road Neighbors retails well above its $72 member price.

The list is free, wait is winery-stated at a few months to a year, and there's no minimum: a member can pass on a release. Spring 2025 Pinot Noirs ran $49-$90, and the flagship Eastside Road Neighbors ($72, back-to-back Wine Spectator Top 10) retails around $90-$100, so buying at release beats the market. The catch is that allocations are first-come, first-served and loyalty-based: the most sought-after vineyard designates sell out within days, and fall priority for the Eastside Road Neighbors goes to spring buyers. Main uncertainty: 2024 prices are behind the member login, and there's no true secondary-market data, only retail asks.

Our take, as of 2026-11-18. How we write these

The list

StatuswaitlistWinery · as of 2026-11-18
Realistic wait2–12 months (n=0; Winery-stated typical wait of "a few months to a year" (min of 2 months reads "a few months"). No usable 2024-2026 forum reports: one 2026 post mentions a 10+ year wait without clear start/end points, and 1989-1990 reports of 2-4+ years are excluded as stale.)Winery · as of 2026-11-18
Minimum purchaseNo stated minimum. Spring 2026 curated selections started at 3 bottles for $182 plus tax and shipping, but members can pick from the full allocation instead.Winery · as of 2026-11-18
Releases per year4Member offer · as of 2026-11-10
Offer window27 daysMember offer · as of 2026-09-07
If you skipA member can pass on a release and is checked in with again before the next one. Allocations depend on membership length, purchase history, referrals and loyalty, and the winery says fall-release priority for its top wine goes to members who bought in the spring.Member offer · as of 2025-03-14
Allocation guaranteeNone. Allocations are not reserved; wines sell first-come, first-served during the release window, and popular wines sell out within days.Winery · as of 2026-11-18
Cost to stay on, per year$364Calculated · as of 2026-03-04

Releases

Price per 750ml bottle. "Secondary" is what the wine sells for after release.

VintageWineReleaseSecondaryDifference
2023Beckstoffer To Kalon Vineyard Cabernet SauvignonUnknownas of 2026-11-18Unknownas of 2026-11-18—
2022Beckstoffer To Kalon Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon$245Member offer · as of 2025-11-10Unknownas of 2026-11-18—
2024Eastside Road Neighbors Pinot NoirUnknownas of 2026-11-18Unknownas of 2026-11-18—
2023Eastside Road Neighbors Pinot Noir$72Winery · as of 2025-02-24$100Release tracker · as of 2026-11-18+39%

Winery website

Get the weekly offer email

One short email a week: which allocation offers are open (Williams Selyem included, when it has one), what closes soon and what's next. Free.

No spam, unsubscribe any time. Privacy.

Something wrong or out of date? Corrections with a source are welcome; see how we source data.